Pop Kulcher

gravatar
Member Since: 7/1/2002
Total Mixes: 376
Total Feedback: 895
Message | Friend

Instant Karma: The John Lennon Anthology

Artist Song Buy
John Lennon  Give Peace A Chance  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Cold Turkey  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Instant Karma!  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Mother  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Working Class Hero  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Isolation  buy on itunes
John Lennon  God  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Power To The People  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Imagine  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Crippled Inside  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Gimme Some Truth  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Oh Yoko!  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Happy Xmas (War Is Over)  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Woman Is The Nigger Of The World  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Mind Games  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Bring On The Lucie (Freda People)  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Whatever Gets You Thru The Night  buy on itunes
John Lennon  #9 Dream  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Watching The Wheels  buy on itunes
John Lennon  Nobody Told Me  buy on itunes

Comment:

After a couple high-effort mixes, time to kick back with a few low-effort single artist mixes. I've always been a bit more partial towards Paul's first solo decade than John's, though both had a handful of highs and a surprising amount (in light of what they'd accomplished together in the 60's) of sheer mediocrity. In Lennon's case, I think the Plastic Ono album remains a solid classic, and Imagine is pretty respectable, but beyond that he was largely a singles act. Which is why this finished product doesn't look radically different from the dozens of commercial greatest-hits anthologies on the market, though with enough personal variation to make it worth the effort. (For validation, I compared it to king-of-the-single-artist-mixes Rob Conroy's Lennon mix and found we'd ended up with a fair amount of overlap, so I'm concluding I got this one just about right.)
image for mix

Feedback:

gravatar
anthony lombardi
Date: 1/20/2008
fairly great compilation of my all-time favorite musical figure - it's an absolute crime to omit "jealous guy," one of the most beautiful, piercing ballads these ears have ever heard, but aside from that you hit most of my favorites. "mind games" & "#9 dream" are largely unappreciated cuts (by the general public, anyhow), & glad to see "cold turkey" made it. i would have made room for "nobody loves you when you're down & out," as well, but that's about as far as i'll go. good stuff, marc.
gravatar
e. buster
Date: 1/20/2008
I was never one for pop idolotry, but the Beatles and particularly Lennon are my exception. What would I like to see included? I agree with Anthony that Jealous Guy is a must have, as us Luck of the Irish. I have always liked Well, Well, Well and, again as Anthony says, Nobody Loves You When You're Down & Out. What would I cut to get those in? #9 Dream has never been near the top of my list. And for a personal listen I wouldn't miss Whatever Gets You Thru the Night, but no self-respecting anthology could omit that. So nit-picking aside, I think this is about as close to a perfect selection as possible in 20 songs.
gravatar
mahdishain
Date: 1/20/2008
i would have no problem with getting rid of Whatever Gets You Thru the Night but otherwise no complaints. my next mix will contain a cover of working class hero that is amazing. guesses accepted.
gravatar
doowad
Date: 1/20/2008
I dunno, Marc, I think I would have gone for 2 CDs just to flesh it out a bit. As you noted, it looks quite a bit like the Shaved Fish anthology, though I am glad to see a couple oddities. The last two are hits, but just remarkable and among my favorite ex-Beatles songs, period.
gravatar
G-Sphere
Date: 1/21/2008
Nice collection. Can't go wrong with any of this stuff.
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 1/21/2008
I'm with you on your solo Lennon assessment 100% and with you on most of these tracks--you're right, I think we have more overlap here than on any other single-artist mix! I'm not very partial to "Power to the People" or "Woman is the...", but I love the couple of other tracks that you included that weren't on my mix.
gravatar
Sean Lally
Date: 1/23/2008
If the guy only ever wrote "isolation", he'd still be a friggin genius in my book.
gravatar
gobi
Date: 3/26/2008
I reckon you 98% nailed it . . . wouldn't jealous guy squeeze on any where ? cut down the gaps between tracks ? Make it an MP3 playlist and not tell anyone ? Nice work, and I really like the detail in the cover pic . . .

You must be logged in to do this.