Pop Kulcher

gravatar
Member Since: 7/1/2002
Total Mixes: 376
Total Feedback: 895
Message | Friend

24 x 24: Come Count Vit Me!

Artist Song Buy
The Who  I'm One  buy on itunes
The Beatles  Two Of Us  buy on itunes
Bob Dorough/Schoolhouse Rock  Three Is A Magic Number  buy on itunes
Flying Burrito Brothers  Four Days Of Rain  buy on itunes
David Bowie  Five Years  buy on itunes
The Cure  Six Different Ways  buy on itunes
Queen  Seven Seas Of Rhye  buy on itunes
R.E.M.  Driver 8  buy on itunes
The Shazam  Nine Times  buy on itunes
The Connells  Ten Pins  buy on itunes
Myracle Brah  Eleven  buy on itunes
Barbara Manning & SF Seals  Day 12  buy on itunes
Big Star  Thirteen  buy on itunes
Guided By Voices  14 Cheerleader Coldfront  buy on itunes
Uncle Tupelo  Fifteen Keys  buy on itunes
Replacements  Sixteen Blue  buy on itunes
Sex Pistols  Seventeen  buy on itunes
West Coast Pop Art Experimental Band  Eighteen Is Over The Hill  buy on itunes
Rolling Stones  19th Nervous Breakdwon  buy on itunes
Amy Rigby  20 Questions  buy on itunes
Bettie Serveert  21 Days  buy on itunes
Flaming Lips  When Yer Twenty Two  buy on itunes
Luna  23 Minutes In Brussels  buy on itunes
Game Theory  24  buy on itunes

Comment:

I'm not a huge fan of gimmicky theme mixes (22 songs with Booger in the title...). While cute in the abstract, they don't always make for the best listening experiences -- and, as purists, we should always make the sound & vibe of the mix paramount, right? -- as the mere fact that you can find two dozen songs about cats doesn't mean they're going to sound any good when played together. That said, they're invariably fun to make, and they do force you, by sheer necessity, to reach for parts of your collection you don't normally turn to when making mixes. (Hence, I've made a few myself, capitalizing on expansive themes of Cross-USA Travel and that old chestnut Days Of The Week.) This one here came out ok, with a decent blend of old favorites and left-field selections. Had to discard a few (Pixies' "No. 13 Baby," R.E.M.'s "Seven Chinese Brothers," Byrds' "Eight Miles High," etc.), and didn't quite have the space for Grant Hart's "Twenty Five Forty One", but the final mix plays fairly well. Divorced from the running order constraints I might have opted to mix it differently (a few too many front-loaded classics and meandering tunes at the end), but such is the world of the dreaded Theme Mix.
image for mix

Feedback:

gravatar
doowad
Date: 7/7/2008
I'm with you on the theme mixes, but I have been guilty myself as well. Queen segueing into R.E.M. is something I surely must try some time. Replacements as a bridge from Tupelo to Pistols makes perfect sense.
gravatar
hemizen
Date: 7/7/2008
I bet you could find 50 ways to leave your lover....
gravatar
anthony lombardi
Date: 7/7/2008
i concur with your liner notes whole-heartedly, & also with derek on the wonderful work-out of that 'mats thru uncle tupelo & the sex pitols segue. 2, 4-8, 13, the aforementioned 15-17 & 19 are all hard-hitters for me.

by the way, thanks a ton for the link to the dynamite jangle pop mix - can't wait to give it a spin.
gravatar
joey de vivre
Date: 7/7/2008
10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 - blast off!
I know just what you mean about pointless gimmickry; I like to think a theme mix justifies itself if you're making it for someone who has a special interest in the subject, or for a special occasion; other times an imposed theme can be a real mixed blessing. At least here it adds up to a number of good tunes . . .
gravatar
Mesh
Date: 7/8/2008
Well stated notes that won't get any argument from me, and actually the major reason I haven't attempted anything like this myself.It's a shame you ditched 7 & 8, but more than made up for it with the Queen/R.E.M. replacements. The 13-17 run looks amazing, and 19 is my favorite Stones song. Very well done....
gravatar
KathrynandRupert
Date: 7/8/2008
I like theme mixes. I don't like things to run smoothly, I want jagged clashes of hostile styles to reflect the abstactness of reality. And I was about to do exactly the same mix and would have used tracks 13, 16, 19 and 23. A fine effort.
gravatar
njr
Date: 7/8/2008
Mix it the way you like it! It's how the inspiration hits you--a single artist, covers, a theme, a style, a birthday gift--and how you feel about making the mix. Well crafted playlist, as usual.
gravatar
Reepicheep
Date: 7/8/2008
awesome especially track six. wonderful idea.
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 7/8/2008
This does seem like a great listening experience, despite my general aversion to these types of things (that you share, according to your notes).
gravatar
e. buster
Date: 7/9/2008
Hmmm... I am not exactly AVERSE to the themed mix ;), but this looks good with or without the gimmick. The 8-14 run looks especially appealing.
gravatar
MarkSmith
Date: 7/10/2008
great stuff all around... love that opening duo, that awesome Bowie track, Big Star, Queen, the closing triplet... and many more inbetween
gravatar
Moe
Date: 7/10/2008
The answer? 576. Plenty of my favorite "numbers" here: Game THeory, Big Star, Reps, early REM, Schoolhouse Rock... Sure, this theme has been done, but never bettered. I was working on my booger theme mix, but I think I'm going to scrap it now.
gravatar
senatorhung
Date: 7/10/2008
i don't have any problem with theme mixes, as long as the resulting mix plays well straight thru. in this case, i think mixing up the track order once the tracks were selected would have been ok.

i appreciate kathrynandrupert's take, but i disagree - the jagged clashes of hostile styles should be *intended* by the mixer, not an accident of following the theme, though happy accidents have been known to occur. just my 2 cents.
gravatar
avocado rabbit
Date: 7/12/2008
Now you're stuck! Someday there will have to be a volume 2 (25-48) and 3 and so on. Love the Amy Rigby track. I met her around the time of her breakup with Will Rigby (drummer for Steve Earle) and I'm sure she played 20 questions a few times with him.

You must be logged in to do this.