Rob Conroy

gravatar
Member Since: 1/22/2001
Total Mixes: 629
Total Feedback: 9267

Another goodbye to another good friend (2 CDs)

Side A
Artist Song
The Rolling Stones  It's All Over Now 
The Rolling Stones  (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction 
The Rolling Stones  Get Off My Cloud 
The Rolling Stones  Paint It, Black 
The Rolling Stones  Miss Amanda Jones 
The Rolling Stones  Back Street Girl 
The Rolling Stones  Ruby Tuesday 
The Rolling Stones  Jumpin' Jack Flash 
The Rolling Stones  Stray Cat Blues 
The Rolling Stones  Street Fighting Man 
The Rolling Stones  Sympathy for the Devil 
The Rolling Stones  You Got the Silver 
The Rolling Stones  Gimme Shelter 
The Rolling Stones  Monkey Man 
The Rolling Stones  Honky Tonk Women 
The Rolling Stones  Wild Horses 
The Rolling Stones  Can't You Hear Me Knocking [edit--I kept 0:00 to 2:58 and ditched the rest] 
The Rolling Stones  Loving Cup 
The Rolling Stones  Happy 
The Rolling Stones  Rocks Off 
Side B
ArtistSongBuy
The Rolling Stones  Coming Down Again 
The Rolling Stones  Angie 
The Rolling Stones  Beast of Burden 
The Rolling Stones  Before They Make Me Run 
The Rolling Stones  All About You 
The Rolling Stones  Little T & A 
The Rolling Stones  Wanna Hold You 
The Rolling Stones  Sleep Tonight 
Keith Richards  Take It So Hard 
Keith Richards  Make No Mistake 
The Rolling Stones  Slipping Away 
Keith Richards  Wicked as It Seems 
Keith Richards  Hate It When You Leave 
The Rolling Stones  Thru and Thru 
The Rolling Stones  The Worst 
The Rolling Stones  Thief in the Night 
The Rolling Stones  Losing My Touch 
The Rolling Stones  This Place is Empty 

Comment:

I have so much to say here that I don't even know where to begin. In a nutshell, this is a heartfelt tribute to the Human Riff/Laboratory, Keith Richards--who is not only my all-time favorite guitarist but is also one of my favorite songwriters, dark-horse vocalists and all-around figures in music history. His reluctance to hog the spotlight has often left him relegated to playing second fiddle to Mick Jagger (I'm always surprised when I hear friends of mine who have very similar tastes to mine proclaim Mick to be the primary reason that the Stones are--traditionally, anyway--the Greatest Rock and Roll Band in the World), and, as a result, I compiled this mix in support of my adamant contention that he is far and away the most compelling figure in the Rolling Stones' 44- or 45 (depending upon whom one asks)-year history. Although these selections are arranged chronologically, they are intended to present an appropriate mosaic of his talents: riff-meister ("Satisfaction," "Can't You Hear Me Knocking," "Happy," "Rocks Off," "Beast of Burden"); soloist ("It's All Over Now," "Sympathy for the Devil"--I actually prefer the Ya-Ya's version of the latter as an overall guitars-and-band performance, but it doesn't include THAT SOLO); vocalist ("You Got the Silver," "Make No Mistake," "Thru and Thru," his backing vocals on "Loving Cup" that MAKE the song as utterly spine-tingling as music gets); songwriter [as the primary musical force behind "Paint It, Black," "Wild Horses" and "Angie," as well as the near-sole composer (with Brian Jones, no less) of "Ruby Tuesday"]; elegantly dissipated balladeer (see any Keef song on any post-Some Girls Stones album, but "All About You" and the last four tracks on disc 2 in particular); and one third of the most tightly-yet-loosely-locked rhythm section in rock 'n' roll's history ("Jumpin' Jack Flash," "Street Fighting Man," "Gimme Shelter," "Monkey Man," "Honky Tonk Women"--really, have there been any rock songs with better intros than those songs? I think not). There were plenty of tracks cut: "Brown Sugar" (because it is essentially a Jagger composition, even if Keith's playing takes it to another level), "Torn & Frayed" (whose first chord is responsible for my wanting a Gibson Hummingbird acoustic more than any possession in this world), "Luxury" (as a consummate lesson in Keef-style rhythm playing), "Memory Motel" (where his short vocal stint makes the entire song worthwhile), "Dead Flowers" (for his backing vocals), "Play with Fire," "As Tears Go By," "Sister Morphine," "You Can't Always Get What You Want" (again, the intro and general level of accompaniment), "Under My Thumb" (passed over despite its title as my favorite Stones song because it's the entire band's performance that renders it immortal instead of just Keith and/or Charlie) and "Out of Time" (see my last comment, amended to "one of my very favorite" Stones songs). I wish Keith continued good health and a long life, especially his by-now-standard "Keef ballads" (whose slowness does drag the pacing of disc 2 down a bit despite their uniform level of quality) are the only reasons I'd ever listen to a modern Stones album. I'm keenly interested in hearing my fellow music geeks' comments on my discussion above, so, by all means, fire away. Thanks to hemizen for tracks 12 and 13 of Disc 2.

Feedback:

gravatar
Sean Lally
Date: 3/6/2007
yeah, but he murdered Brian Jones!

:-)
gravatar
Mr. Mirage
Date: 3/6/2007
Poor Brian...
gravatar
anthony lombardi
Date: 3/7/2007
i actually have to back you up on this one, rob. recently, my father lent me a copy of talk is cheap to check out, & i remember nearly mocking him -- because i hate mick jagger's solo work (all flair, no heart), so i recall saying something to the effect of "stones solo albums don't really do much for me." after a week or so of putting it off, i gave it a spin & man was i surprised at how goddamn great it was -- i even made myself a copy. so, hats off to keith -- & of course to you for making this. definitely my favorite stones member, & one of my favorite guitarists of all-time too.
gravatar
hemizen
Date: 3/7/2007
The reason I like Keith is he doesn't have to find the spotlight, the spotlight finds him. Riff on....
gravatar
Sean Lally
Date: 3/7/2007
OK, to be serious... I like Keith, I like Mick. I don't really like either of them solo (as opposed to the John/Paul argument). Mick is one of the greatest frontman in rock and roll history (along with the likes of Iggy Pop) - the fact that he no longer really "sings" is beside the point. He represents total rock and roll goofiness and abandon - and he's ugly as sin, but the womens liked him.

However, why I like the sound of the Stones is probably all in Charlie Watts. And like so many other bands, I lose interest rapidly after their 60s output.
gravatar
Sean Lally
Date: 3/7/2007
One other comment - without Mick, whose vocals I'm not even particularly fond of, I really doubt that the Stones would have attracted that much attention - he was the focal point. And Brian was a much better harmonica player :-)
gravatar
brad32
Date: 3/7/2007
i've always liked the stones, yet never saw the need to get any albums (hey, you could hear 'em on the radio practically anytime) until a coupla years ago. man, what i've been missing!! two of my favorites are on here - stray cat blues and little t&a - and the rest ain't bad either. would love to hear this...
gravatar
Mark Petruccelli
Date: 3/7/2007
I've never really looked at the Stones' work from a Keith-centric perspective but it does turn out that a majority of your examples here fall into the My Favorites category. (Brown Suger and Under My Thumb not withstanding,) Another impressive labor of love here. Gotta love a guy that falls out of a coconut tree at 60+ and survives. To paraphrase Bill Hicks: "After the Nuclear Holocausr the only two things remaining will be roaches and Keith Richards ... "I saw a bright light and I thought we were on!"
gravatar
Pop Kulcher
Date: 3/7/2007
While I obviously can't quarrel with any of this, allow me to chime in here with the alternative view -- that the Stones were at their very best when Mick Taylor was in the band. The Keef-Mick twin guitar attack was the best (and, not coincidentally, they had their best run of records -- Let It Bleed, Sticky Fingers, and Exile On Main Street -- during that era (though that had as much to do with the songwriting as the performance). Still, you're undeniably right that Keith's contributions to the band are immeasurable, and the string of pre-Bleed singles was second only to the Beatles.

I can't claim to be familiar with anything on this post-"Little T&A," which was pretty much the last Stones I bothered with. And I'm curious about "Can't You Hear Me Knocking" -- did you edit out the first 3 minutes, or edit out everything after the first 3 minutes? Personally, the long jam is my favorite part of the song; sure, it's essentially a Santana rip-off, but a damn fine one.
gravatar
French Connection
Date: 3/7/2007
"And after all is said and done..." I don't have many musical heroes but Keef is one of em and after Goats Head Soup, Keefs vocals are the only reason I bothered to continue buying Stones albums (goes without saying his fret work is a tad special)Nice one Rob.
gravatar
sammyg123
Date: 3/7/2007
Incredible first disc. As this is chronological I don't know as much on Disc 2 as I haven't checked out a few of their latter day albums. Huge fan of both Mick & Keef though...
gravatar
Barrydali
Date: 3/8/2007
Curiously enough I have never been a fan. they are one of those bands that I just never got into for whatever reason. That said, the songs I do dig are all represented here and to my mind Gimme Shelter eclipses everything else by some distance, but as I say I'm not really qualified here.
gravatar
Orchid
Date: 3/10/2007
Like you, I have so much to say here that I don't even know where to begin. Bottomline, I'm thrilled to see a Rolling Stones mix where Mick Jagger is in the background. He is such an idiot.
gravatar
Orchid
Date: 3/10/2007
Oh, and I agree with Barrydali that 'Gimme Shelter' eclipses everything here, as well as 99.9998% of all known songs on the Earth. ('Everybody's Talkin' is also one of the .00002%)
gravatar
Dom1
Date: 3/19/2007
Like most 60's bands their albums are choc a block with filler which makes a good case for buying a Greatest Hits package like Rolled Gold - heard like that The Stones are simply unbeatable. I'm not however saying all their albums are dispensable - I wouldn't be without Sticky Fingers! Yeah Keef in the 60's and early 70's defined R'N'Roll. Disc 1 is hard to argue with, Disc 2 has more than a few gems but late Stones do nothing for me.
gravatar
doowad
Date: 10/12/2007
I love everything about this, especially disk two. My biggest criticism of him personally was his criticizing the Verve for 'stealing' that Stones' riff, when Keef has 'borrowed' quite generously from our Chuck. That just sounded too much like old fart hypocrisy, but needless to say, he is the epitome of rock n' roll and the art of guitar. As I've said before, even if he had never been famous, he would still be bumming around, playing the clubs, perhaps akin to Henry Townsend, to drop another St. Louis name.