Rob Conroy

gravatar
Member Since: 1/22/2001
Total Mixes: 629
Total Feedback: 9267

The overwhelming dream of happiness (2 CDs)

Side A
Artist Song
American Music Club  Big Night 
American Music Club  Outside This Bar 
American Music Club  Nightwatchman 
American Music Club  Firefly 
American Music Club  Somewhere 
American Music Club  Lonely 
American Music Club  Blue and Grey Shirt 
American Music Club  Jenny 
American Music Club  Western Sky 
American Music Club  Last Harbor 
American Music Club  Heaven of Your Hands 
American Music Club  Kathleen 
American Music Club  The Hula Maiden 
American Music Club  Why Won't You Stay 
American Music Club  Rise 
American Music Club  Crabwalk 
American Music Club  The Dead Part of You 
American Music Club  What the Pillar of Salt Held Up 
American Music Club  Jesus' Hands 
American Music Club  Gratitude Walks 
American Music Club  If I Had a Hammer 
American Music Club  I've Been a Mess 
American Music Club  Hollywood 4-5-92 
Side B
ArtistSongBuy
American Music Club  What Godzilla Said to God When His Name Wasn't Found in the Book of Life 
American Music Club  Keep Me Around 
American Music Club  Apology for an Accident 
American Music Club  Johnny Mathis' Feet 
American Music Club  Will You Find Me? 
American Music Club  Fearless 
American Music Club  What Holds This World Together 
American Music Club  The Thorn in My Side is Gone 
American Music Club  Ladies and Gentlemen 
American Music Club  Another Morning 
American Music Club  Patriot's Heart 
American Music Club  Home 
American Music Club  All My Love 
American Music Club  The John Berchman Victory Choir 
American Music Club  The Sleeping Beauty 
American Music Club  All the Lost Souls Welcome You to San Francisco 
American Music Club  The Windows on the World 
American Music Club  I Know That's Not Really You 
American Music Club  Long Long Walk 

Comment:

My revised double-disc set (again, turned into a continuous "anthology"-style set instead of the two-self-contained-discs setup that I used more often in the past) from one of the greatest live bands that I've ever seen (both of their last two Pittsburgh shows would probably rank somewhere in the ballpark of my top ten) and one of the most unjustly overlooked recording acts in recent memory. Yes, they've sold more records than a lot of bands, but they seem to fall in the Redd Kross/Lemonheads/Posies gap with the listening public, where they are a bit too "dark" or unusual or "quirky" to connect with a mass audience despite being signed to a major label for at least part of their career but they aren't quite quirky *enough* to appeal to the average hipster (who often shuns acts on major labels, as well). [To elaborate for a minute after reading Marc's and Rupert's comments below: I'm certainly not saying all music snobs care what label a band is on--I certainly don't, for one, although I agree with Marc about the effect that major-label signing seems to have on the vast majority of bands who wind up signing to them--but note that being on a major seems to kill the word-of-mouth "buzz" that hipster tastemakers (whoever they are) often generate and also note that, conversely, these bands never get the major-label marketing to a mass audience due to the edges that would endear them to music snobs in the first place, thus placing the bands in a bit of a vacuum that's tough to fill.] Mark Eitzel is an amazing vocalist and an impressive songwriter, Vudi's guitar soundscapes are edgy and atmospheric in all of the right ways, and their latest album (The Golden Age) is their best since 1993's Mercury. There were plenty of songs cut to keep this at two discs, most notably "Sick of Food," "Who You Are," "Decibels and Little Pills," "Myopic Books," "The Dance," "Dallas, Ariports, Bodybags," "Never Mind," "Job to Do" and "For the Good Times."

Feedback:

gravatar
Pop Kulcher
Date: 4/20/2008
All the right people swear by this band... I think I made the mistake of checking them out, like, 15 years ago, and they were just too melancholy for me and I didn't latch on. Of course, 15 years older now, and far more welcoming of such downbeat sounds, so I think it's time for another listen.
I find your observation about signing to a major label intriguing, and I'm thinking about it... I personally have never stopped likeing a band because they've signed to a major label, though I've often lost interest in a band right afterwards -- which I tend to think because a lot of once-indie bands often start becoming boring right around that time. Maybe because the big buck contracts force them to remove some of the edges that made them interesting in the first place, maybe because a lot of times the major labels don't get smart enough to sign a great band until much of their best work is behind them.
gravatar
KathrynandRupert
Date: 4/20/2008
I don't care what label a band is signed to, if I like them I like them.

I only have one AMC LP which I bought about 15 years ago and it never quite reeled me in. I'd tell you which one but I'm at the girlfriend's parent's house and don't have access to the record collection. But they are a band I've been meaning to return to and when I get home I'll give the LP a listen.
gravatar
hemizen
Date: 4/21/2008
As of this moment I have 20,252 tracks on my computer and not one by American Music Club (thought I have heard them before).
gravatar
Funky Ratchet
Date: 4/21/2008
Familiar with these guys in name only...I really need to fix that.
gravatar
mahdishain
Date: 4/21/2008
your enthusiasm entices me to investigate. thanks!
gravatar
blasikin
Date: 4/21/2008
My girlfriend loves. I'm going to have to follow the last three guys.
gravatar
doowad
Date: 4/21/2008
Wow, pleading utter and total ignorance here, I'm with Tom though.
gravatar
Mark Petruccelli
Date: 4/21/2008
I'm another un-exposed but interested one here. Can I assume that their new disc is a good place to start?
gravatar
sport !
Date: 4/21/2008
I loved this band a while back and just started listening again to California (the best starting point, perhaps?).
Well played, Sir!
gravatar
lemonadesky
Date: 4/22/2008
I'm kind of in the Pop Kulcher camp on this one, never having been taken with this band or Eitzel's solo work for that matter. I do applaud your efforts, however. Perhaps one day I'll give them another chance.
gravatar
anthony lombardi
Date: 4/22/2008
a band that, for one reason or another, i've never gotten around to checking out - the good reception around their new album has certainly intrigued me though, as does this - any chance of a link?
gravatar
G-Sphere
Date: 4/22/2008
Like others here I checked this band out many years ago and was not all that impressed. With that said... I do like their new album a lot.
gravatar
sammyg123
Date: 4/25/2008
Happy Birthday Rob. Sorry for the lame comment, but I know nothing here :(