from Trampoline
(2007)
Found out about this band through Reddit. This song starts the mix of relatively uptempo, if not upbeat.
First Aid Kit
Tiger Mountain Peasant Song
from Drunken Trees
(2008)
Cover of song by Fleet Foxes. Pretty sure I originally heard about First Aid Kit through Reddit. I love their harmonies on this song.
Grupo Fantasma
El Sabio Soy Yo
from Sonidos Gold
Heard about this band via an album review by my PSYC100 professor. He was such a ridiculously kick-ass prof. Inasmuch as the mixtape has an arc, this is a dance wherein the boy meets the girl.
Ramona Falls
I Say Fever
from Intuit
(2009)
If I'm not mistaken, I heard about Ramona Falls from some MP3 blogger's top picks of 2009. That first "I Say Fever" just kicks my ass every time (in a good way). Also, the video is really trippy. Check it out. The boy wants to get close to the girl but everyone's advising him to play it slow.
Ra Ra Riot
Can You Tell
from The Rhumb Line
Ra Ra Riot is one of my favorite bands, and this song is a close second for my favorite song on The Rhumb Line (which honor goes to Dying Is Fine - that one just doesn't match the mix). The lyric "my bed is too big for just me" strikes me just the right way. The boy says to hell with it and starts actually courting the girl.
The Avett Brothers
Kick Drum Heart
from I and Love and You
(2009)
The Avett Brothers are another of my favorite bands. I can't think of a single song of theirs I don't like. The central analogy of the song is funny and clever ("my heart like a kick drum, my love like a foot"), and the last line is just perfect: "it's not the chase that I love, it's me following you". The boy and the girl have started a serious relationship
Relient K
Must Have Done Something Right
from Fivescore And Seven Years Ago
I like most of Relient K's nonreligious songs, but lately I've found that my past delight in their sound has somewhat worn off. Still, this song is quintessential Relient K, and the first couple of lines are cute and clever ("we should get jerseys, 'cause we make a good team; but yours would look better than mine, 'cause you're out of my league"). The boy is completely enamored with the girl.
White Winter Hymnal
Fleet Foxes
from Fleet Foxes
(2008)
I love Fleet Foxes' folksy sound, and the harmonies in this song are lazy languid lovely. Time passes, apparently pleasantly, but there's a hint of foreboding, as the lyrics don't match the sound at all ("you would fall and turn the white snow red like strawberries in the summertime" - implying metaphorical bleeding in the snow; plus the mention of "red scarves" "to keep their little heads from falling in the snow" sounds somewhat sinister)
Grizzly Bear
Two Weeks
from Veckatimest
(2009)
Grizzly Bear has a very unique sound (at least in my library), and this is one of their better-known songs. The boy and the girl have been fighting, and life is no longer as pleasant ("a routine malaise" - "i told you i would stay" - "would you always, maybe sometimes...?")
Funkadelic
Maggot Brain
from Maggot Brain
(2005)
Alternate Mix. I love the guitar on this track. The relationship is slowly falling apart; the guitar represents the emotional anguish the two feel.
Okkervil River
Unless It's Kicks
from The Stage Names
(2007)
I love Okkervil River; I think they are a hugely underrated band, and this song is just one of many that shows how awesome they are. The couple is temporarily back together again, hence another uptempo song ("when I am fixed, I am convinced that I will not get so broke up again").
Glasvegas
It's My Own Cheating Heart That Makes Me Cry
from Glasvegas
(2008)
Glasvegas has a very wall-of-sound (shoegaze) approach to music, and they're one of the few bands that pulls off the style well enough to make me like it. The lyrics of this song perfectly capture a cheating paranoid boyfriend. The relationship is over with the end of the song ("the end was always coming and now it's here . . . it's my own cheating heart that makes me cry").
Tilly and the Wall
Pot Kettle Black
from O
(2008)
Tilly and the Wall are one of my favorite lighthearted bands, though you wouldn't know it from this song. Their percussion comes primarily from a tapdancer in their band, which is a really cute concept and works surprisingly well in a lot of their songs. This song isn't much like most of their earlier songs, but it's still quite catchy. The boy and the girl now pretty much hate each other ("pot kettle, pot kettle black; talk that, talk that smack!" - delivered with such disdain)
Mark Ronson
Just
from Version
(2007)
Cover of a song by Radiohead. Featuring Alex Greenwald of Phantom Planet. The boy still has feelings for the girl (he just can't sort himself out), and he's jealous of her current boyfriend, so he's making fun of her ("can't get the stink out, he's been hanging 'round for days"; "suckered you, but not your friends" - everyone knows you're an idiot for being with this guy; "you do it to yourself - you and no one else" - he just can't stand that she [in his mind] ruined what they had together).
Deer Tick
Baltimore Blues No. 1
from War Elephant
(2007)
Heard about Deer Tick through Reddit originally, they were part of a pretty big blues kick I was on for a while, and I still like their sound. This one is mostly in the mix for the feel, more than relevant lyrics. The boy is just completely melancholy.
R. L. Burnside
Hard Time Killing Floor
from Wish I Was In Heaven Sitting Down
(2001)
Same as with Deer Tick - Reddit introduced me to R. L. Burnside when I couldn't get enough blues, and I still love his voice and guitar. This is a cover of a really famous blues song originally by Skip James, but Burnside seems to be working from a completely different conception of the song's chords, and his voiceovers are a bonechilling addition. The boy has tried to move on, but he finds "hard times everywhere [he goes]".
Elbow
The Bones of You
from The Seldom Seen Kid
(2008)
I'm not sure how I first heard about Elbow; it might have been through hypemachine. In any case, this is hands down my favorite track by them. The jangly guitar, the rollicking rhythm, the amazing lyrics, the soaring haunting melody; this whole song is just perfect. The boy is now somewhat older, but he still can't forget the girl:
So I'm there
Charging around with a juggernaut brow
Overdraft, speeches and deadlines to make
Cramming commitments like cats in a sack
Telephone burn and a purposeful gait
When out of a doorway the tentacles stretch
Of a song that I know
And the world moves in slow-mo
Straight to my head
like the first cigarette of the day
And it's you, and it's May
And we're sleeping through the day
And I'm five years ago
And three thousand miles away
Do I have
time? A man of my calibre
Stood in the street like a sleepwalking teenager
No.
And I dealt with this years ago
I took a hammer to every memento
But image on image like beads on a rosary
pulled through my head as the music takes hold
and the sickener hits; I can work till I break
but I love the bones of you
That, I will never escape
And it's you, and it's May
And we're sleeping through the day
And I'm five years ago
And three thousand miles away
And I can't move my arm
Through the fear that you will wake
And I'm five years ago
And three thousand miles away
Guillemots
Trains to Brazil
from Through The Windowpane
(2006)
The Guillemots are another strong contender for the position of my favorite band, and this track is a large part of the reason for that. The laughing, whistles, and talking in the first few seconds really help build up the song, they're practically another instrument. The brass interlude is pretty kick-ass, too. The boy is finally starting to accept that he won't be with the girl ever again, though he still reminisces ("I think of you on cold winter mornings, darling they remind me of when we were in school" "but i won't get me down, i'm just happy to be facing the day"). Though the real meaning of the song is a little bittersweet, for the purposes of this mix, this track is a purely upbeat one to bring the mix to a close.
Comment:
Made for spongypancakes as part of /r/mixcd's second mixtape exchange.