Rob Conroy

gravatar
Member Since: 1/22/2001
Total Mixes: 629
Total Feedback: 9267

Live the rest of your life in a day

Artist Song
Jethro Tull  Someday the Sun Won't Shine for You 
Jethro Tull  Cat's Squirrel 
Jethro Tull  A Song for Jeffrey 
Jethro Tull  Christmas Song 
Jethro Tull  Sweet Dream 
Jethro Tull  Fat Man [BBC session] 
Jethro Tull  With You There to Help Me 
Jethro Tull  Alive and Well and Living In 
Jethro Tull  For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me 
Jethro Tull  Inside 
Jethro Tull  Sossity; You're a Woman 
Jethro Tull  Just Trying to Be 
Jethro Tull  Cross-Eyed Mary 
Jethro Tull  Cheap Day Return 
Jethro Tull  Mother Goose 
Jethro Tull  Wond'ring Aloud 
Jethro Tull  My God 
Jethro Tull  Hymn 43 
Jethro Tull  Life's a Long Song 
Jethro Tull  Up the 'pool 
Jethro Tull  Nursie 
Jethro Tull  Skating Away on the Thin Ice of the New Day 

Comment:

As an extension of my prog mix, I thought I'd follow the impulse and compile 80 minutes' worth of my favorite "guilty pleasure" prog band (using CDs almost entirely borrowed from my friend Jon, to give him proper credit). (For the record, I don't consider King Crimson, Gabriel-era Genesis, Amon Duul II, Can, the Soft Machine, Gong, Hawkwind, the Red Krayola, pre-"Dark Side" Pink Floyd, Van der Graaf Generator or a fair amount of Traffic to be guilty pleasures, as I embrace them wholeheartedly). All of this material save the last tune (which is actually my favorite song by the band) is culled from their first five albums, although I didn't have access to a copy of "Stand Up" (I made due, however, by including a "live-on-the-BBC" version of my favorite track from that album on this disc). As is almost always the case, it's a shame that there wasn't room for the entire first side of "Thick as a Brick", "Teacher", "Bouree", "Serenade to a Cuckoo", "Wind Up", "Wond'ring Again" and "Witch's Promise", among others. Those who actually give a shit should take heart that a sequel will not be forthcoming.

Feedback:

gravatar
McDonald12
Date: 6/16/2002
Lots of goodies Rob. This, and the entire aqualung album are the very best of Tull.
gravatar
lo-fi jr.
Date: 6/16/2002
I think it's the codpiece & flute that causes shame in closet fans of Tull. I'll extend my own guilt trip all the way up to Songs From The Woods.
gravatar
Moe
Date: 6/17/2002
I don't care what anyone says -- they deserved that Grammy for best hard rock band! Sorry that Living in the Past didn't make the cut. I played it while showing slides of a renaissance fair in my junior high photography class a long long time ago.
gravatar
Sean Lally
Date: 6/17/2002
We've talked about this before but, I think you give short shrift to the material after this. I will stand behind just about every album up to (and including) 'A'. True, I haven't listened to them deeply in nearly 20 years, but many tunes still stand out to me. "Songs from the Wood", "Too old to rock n roll", and more. Yes, I think that Ian Anderson can be considered a little corny. Personally, though, I think it's cool that he almost never changed his schtick during the heyday of the band. This is a fine mix, but I'll second the notion that all of Aqualung is worthy of the mix. Hey, I'm not bitching or anything. I just think Tull is unfairly maligned with so many other prog bands - they were more than just prog. They were blues, folk, political, philosophical, hard rock, and blah blah blah blah....
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 6/17/2002
Thanks for the support, fellas. FYI: I didn't say that Jethro Tull never made a good record after "Thick as a Brick", although I think they were undeniably spotty after that point. Let's think about it, friends: "A Passion Play", "War Child" and "Too Old to Rock 'n' Roll" suck (as songs and as albums) and both "Stormwatch" and "A" are passable at best. But even though "Songs from the Wood" is quite fine (if not marred by its thin late-70's production) and "Minstrel in the Gallery" is almost as good as any of their first five, is there really a single song from those records that you'd include before any of the stuff on my mix?
gravatar
Jana
Date: 6/17/2002
This is very cool! I was just looking at Jethro Tull CDs at the uni library, along with Gabriel-era Genesis, ELP, Pink Floyd, David Bowie and Brian Eno. I was surprised at the rather extensive collection, considering most of what they have is classical. "Skating Away" is my favourite tune of theirs. I think I'll have to check the rest of them out.
gravatar
Scott K
Date: 6/17/2002
Another fine one Rob. I would want to include Songs From The Wood, as well as Teacher and Moths, though it'd take more time than I have at work to tell you which songs I'd drop.
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 6/17/2002
Hey there, Jana. ;-) You should avoid ELP and post-"Obscured by Clouds" Pink Floyd at all costs, but should most definitely check out the other bands/artists that you named. I'll happily ship this mix along to you once I clear out some of my other obligations...
gravatar
spanielrage
Date: 6/17/2002

boo!

:)
gravatar
katherine light
Date: 6/17/2002
oh man rob, this mix is fantastic. i remember the first tull i ever heard was when i was about seven...my mother was playing aqualung. since then i have loved them. partly because i am hopelessly nostalgic, and partly because they're awesome. especially like your choice to use the bbc version of fat man. too bad thick as a brick couldn't be added as it is my favorite album.
gravatar
teapin
Date: 6/19/2002
my 9th grade math teacher loved these guys. that was enough to turn my heart against them forever. forever!
gravatar
Jana
Date: 6/19/2002
Thanks for the advice Rob. At this point, I'm mostly interested in the Genesis CDs. I forget to mention they had a lot of Yes discs too. They must have a course on Prog or something.
gravatar
p the swede
Date: 7/9/2002
i think i'm with teapin this time, Ian Anderson used to have joker outfit doesn't he?
gravatar
capslock
Date: 11/21/2003
"flute rock, tina! flute rock! you'll never understand this stuff!" - jimmy fallon