Pop Kulcher

gravatar
Member Since: 7/1/2002
Total Mixes: 376
Total Feedback: 895

When The Music's Over: A Doors Anthology

Artist Song
The Doors  Break On Through 
The Doors  Moonlight Drive 
The Doors  Waiting For The Sun 
The Doors  L.A. Woman 
The Doors  Indian Summer 
The Doors  Peace Frog 
The Doors  I Looked At You 
The Doors  Riders On The Storm 
The Doors  Touch Me 
The Doors  Hyacinth House 
The Doors  Take It As It Comes 
The Doors  Strange Days 
The Doors  When The Music's Over 
The Doors  Hello, I Love You 
The Doors  Shaman's Blues 
The Doors  People Are Strange 
The Doors  The Wasp (Texas Radio & The Big Beat) 
The Doors  The E_nd 

Comment:

I'm never quite sure whether the Doors should count as a guilty pleasure or not. While they were hugely popular in their day, and remain a classic rock radio mainstay, critics (and particularly those with hipster cred) seem pretty divided on whether they are a band worthy of continued admiration or a bloated, pretentious joke. I personally waver. There's a lot to dislike. Even setting aside the cult of Jim Morrison, you've got lyrics that range from the hysterically overwrought to the hopelessly banal, some keyboards that often verge into headache territory, and music that often relies on stale blues riffs. Still, Morrison's baritone is one of the most striking in rock (alongside Joy Division's Ian Curtis), some of the poppier tunes are inarguably timeless, and some of the longer, jammier tunes (helped out by Krieger's underrated guitar lines and, yes, sometimes even Manzarke's keyboards) are hypnotically compelling. Plus, sonically, the albums (released in various remastered iterations) sound much, much better than almost anything else recorded at that time. So, on balance, I can easily handpick 80 minutes that, for all the fm radio overplay, I still enjoy hearing (in moderation).
image for mix

Feedback:

gravatar
Pop Kulcher
Date: 12/13/2008
Here's the cover:
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 12/13/2008
I'm with you on absolutely everything in your commentary (with the possible exception of the "stale blues riffs" statement... I really like Robby Krieger and apparently you do, too, as you mentioned later). However, I've just decided to embrace them after wavering and, as I think you know, put together a two-disc mix earlier this year. This mix features my favorite Doors song ("Moonlight Drive"), as well as several others that I really love ("Indian Summer," "Peace Frog," "The WASP," "The E nd"), and for the most part features tracks that made my mix. Were I to quibble, I'd say that "Shaman's Blues" and "Hyacinth House" are weak tracks and that I'm not super-fond of "I Looked at You," "Hello, I Love You" and (to a lesser extent) "Waiting for the Sun." Nice single-disc set, though.
gravatar
SteveRaglin
Date: 12/13/2008
In their short career together, Krieger and company spawned both iconic classics and decidedly self-indulgent crapola. But I remain a fan.
gravatar
avocado rabbit
Date: 12/17/2008
That's an excellent assessment of the band. I have to say I'm a non-guilty fan. Their first album and Morrison Hotel stand out as gems. Thanks for the 80 minutes.