you can't end with Unforgiven 2, just because it's not a strong enough song. If you aren't tired and want to try again..I suggest putting some S&M, live binge and purge as well as a few garage day songs. You'd need a few cd's to justify Metallica's catalouge.

Yeah, but that's the trick is to just make one CD. It's an interesting challenge. I'm not a big Metallica fan, but I'm familiar enough with their music that this comp sounds like a good chunk of their stuff. Single CD mixes can rarely be completist.

Metallica is a very tough band to make a mix for. First of all, most of their songs are at least 5 minutes. Secondly, they have alot of great songs that weren't hits. I suppose the easiest thing to do is to make one cd of their standard literature..and another mix cd of their "b" sides.