Now That's What I Call Holden!

Artist Song
The Ataris  If You Really Want To Hear About It 
The Smiths  The Headmaster Ritual 
Chicago Soundtrack  Razzle Dazzle 
The Beach Boys  Caroline, No  
Rusty Anderson  Electric Trains  
Fountains of Wayne  Leave The Biker  
John Lennon  I'm Stepping Out  
Billie Holiday  You're So Desirable  
The Mr. T Experience  Even Hitler Had A Girlfriend  
Ella Fitzgerald  Just One of Those Things  
The White Stripes  We Are Going To Be Friends 
Big Bad Voodoo Daddy  You & Me & the Bottle Makes 3 
The Who  Trick Of The Light  
The Flaming Lips  Fight Test  
George Harrison  P2 Vatican Blues 
They Might Be Giants  Museum of Idiots  
Louis Prima & his New Orleans Gang  Tin Roof Blues 
Ben Folds Five  Army  
Monty Python  Nudge Nudge, Wink Wink 
Of Montreal  It's Easy To Sleep When You're Dead  
Paul McCartney  I'm Carrying 
The Cure  Catch  
The Magnetic Fields  Nothing Matters When We're Dancing  
R.E.M.  Sad Professor  
The Kinks  Waterloo Sunset 
Sonny Curtis  Love Is All Around 

Comment:

A chapter-by-chapter mix based on The Catcher In The Rye. 1. This song is based on Catcher In The Rye and is an excellent way to start off a soundtrack to the book. 2. Holden's visit with Old Spencer is symbolized by this song about a disillusioned schoolchild. 3. Holden's lies cause him much consternation, but he still remains fairly proud of his ability to pull off such untruths, as does the narrator of this song. 4. Holden views Jane as a symbol of all the innocence inherent in childhood, and this song represents his sadness at such innocence being lost. 5. This song was written about Anderson's dead younger brother, and its nostalgia about artifacts of childhood mirrors Holden's reminiscence about Allie and his baseball glove. 6. This song not only represents Holden's irritation about Stradlater going out with Jane, but the descriptions of the biker also call to mind Holden's hatred of poor personal hygenie. 7. Ironically enough, this track, used here to represent Holden `stepping out' of Pencey Prep, was recorded mere months before Lennon was shot by a deranged fan obsessed with Catcher In The Rye. 8. When Holden meets Mrs. Morrow on the train, he finds her almost as attractive as the protagonist in this song. 9. Looking out his apartment window, Holden sees many lovers fooling around and becomes despondent over the lack of respect between boyfriends and girlfriends. This song would likely hit close to home for Holden. 10. At the Lavender Room, Holden overhears this song playing, and as such it is a perfect soundtrack for his evening. 11. Holden's memories about playing checkers and holding hands with Jane exhibit the same sweet innocence as this song. 12. Holden continues his long night with a stop at Ernie's, where he drowns his sorrows in the kind of alcoholic beverage extolled in this ditty. 13. Holden's encounter with a prostitute is mirrored by this song, as is his attitude of sympathy to ladies of the night. 14. After being pummeled by Maurice, he admits to the readers that he is not much of a fighter, a point of view evoked in this song. 15. Talking to a group of nuns, Holden begins to criticize Catholics in much the same way as Harrison does in this tune. 16. This song combines Holden's love of the Museum of Natural History with his friendship with Pheobe ("if you and I had any brains, we wouldn't be in this place"). 17. Another song Holden reports hearing, this time on his date with Sally to Radio City Music Hall. 18. Based on D.B.'s anecdotes about the army, Holden decides that the military life isn't for him, but his consideration of the idea is effectively conveyed in this song. 19. This sketch parallels neatly with Holden's juvenile and purile conversation with Luce at the bar. 20. Holden's musings about death and the people that are left behind are universal, and this song is another manifestation of them. 21. This song brings to mind the gentle image of a loving Holden visiting Phoebe in the middle of the night. 22. It's sort of an obvious pun, but Holden's desire to `catch' and protect people reflects Robert Smith's tale of a failed relationship. 23. Holden and Phoebe dancing is an exceptionally sweet image, and this song matches its sweetness. 24. Mr. Antolini is not neccessarily a sad professor, but he is very drunk and he speaks in similarly important terms. This song's sleepy vibe echoes Holden's drowsiness, as well. 25. At the end of the chapter, Holden has his first uncritical moment, where he just sits back and enjoys the beauty of Phoebe's moment, just like the narrator enjoying the beauty of Terry and Julie's night out. 26. He's gonna make it after all! (cut to Holden jumping and throwing his hunting hat up in the air)

Feedback:

gravatar
It's funny how often I've seen people use this theme on AOTM.
gravatar
les_autres
Date: 5/31/2005
I think this is a very good, original idea! I love what you've done with it. Great work, and a very nice collection of songs. I think Holden, if not Saliger, would approve. Too bad there's no song called "What I Really Hate Are Phonies."
gravatar
Mr. Bun
Date: 5/31/2005
I think it's been done before because Holden was sort of the godfather of the whole angst-rock revolution. I did this mix for a homework assignment to assign a few songs to Caulfield's personality, but since I'm an overachieving mixtape junkie, I went ahead and made it a whole CD. Selecting songs based on the chapters introduced a natural dynamic to the mix (especially noticeable on tracks 21-24).
gravatar
Dead Poet
Date: 5/31/2005
This is a really creative mix. Bravo!
gravatar
Bitter Fire
Date: 5/31/2005
Wow! A wonderful idea! I love it!
gravatar
Mixxer
Date: 5/31/2005
Bravo, adding this to "The Reading Room Annex" - check it out at AOTM Exhibitions page.
gravatar
Rob Conroy
Date: 5/31/2005
This is always a welcome theme since, even at 34, The Catcher in the Rye remains my favorite book of all-time. Nice mix.
gravatar
The Nightcrawler
Date: 5/31/2005
Man . . . great job! I knew this would be a shoe-in for The Reading Room. Thanks for the extensive notes.
gravatar
Dead Man
Date: 6/1/2005
I really have to hand it to you. This mix is amazingly well done. I've read The Catcher in the Rye a couple of times and I'm fascinated with it. Not only is Salinger's life an enigma, but the book has taken on an aura of its own, including Mark David Chapman's obsession with it that led him to shoot John Lennon. Again, great mix. Patrick C. Taylor's comment is puzzling to me here. I did a number of searches to find other Catcher in the Rye mixes and I found a few, but yours is the best developed mix and it appears to be the best listen. Take a bow, Mr. Bun.
gravatar
hemizen
Date: 6/1/2005
Excellent theme and execution!
gravatar
Pollyanna
Date: 6/1/2005
"Catcher in the Rye", is one of my all-time favorites, too. Good idea for a mix and excellent choices!
gravatar
Salman1
Date: 6/1/2005
This mix excellent. I thought "Catcher in the Rye" was one of the most overrated books in high school, but I've grown to really really like it now.
gravatar
locovinagre
Date: 6/6/2005
This is fantastic, don't know how I missed it when it was posted. The book is my favorite and now this mix is also my AOTM favorite.
gravatar
bungeeless jumper
Date: 6/6/2005
it doesn't need my comment to shine but still i feel it my duty to tell what an exceptional treasure you've created!loud applouse ladies&gents!
gravatar
Saaf
Date: 6/6/2005
A "booktrack?" Sounds like we need a new category. Great job. Makes me want to re-read it.
gravatar
_Ellie
Date: 6/13/2005
Amen to the new category needed. Nicely done, laddie.
gravatar
dj faustus
Date: 1/21/2006
Good mix, but where's Smoke Gets In Your Eyes?